ShadowTalk AI vs Proton Lumo — encrypted AI, compared honestly
The short answer
Proton Lumo encrypts stored chat history with zero-access encryption — but inference is cloud-only: Lumo's published security model documents the server decrypting your prompt to process it, and you need an account and a live connection. ShadowTalk AI adds the missing half — an on-device model with zero network egress — plus E2EE Private Mode (AES-256-GCM) and BYOK across 16+ providers.
Proton's privacy pedigree is real, and we credit it below. But the encrypted-AI camp has a structural gap: encryption around storage while the cloud still sees the prompt. This page maps exactly where the two products differ — including the limits we ship in public and they don't have to admit because their defaults are different.
Proton Lumo vs ShadowTalk AI, dimension by dimension
| Dimension | ShadowTalk AI | Proton Lumo |
|---|---|---|
| Offline use | Yes — on-device inference, zero network egress after model download | No — cloud-only; no connection, no answers |
| Where your prompt is processed | On your device (WebGPU mode) or at your chosen provider via BYOK — direct browser-to-provider, no ShadowTalk proxy | Proton servers — Lumo's security model documents decrypting the prompt server-side to answer |
| Account required | No — guests chat immediately | Yes — Proton account |
| Stored-history encryption | Private Mode: end-to-end AES-256-GCM, keys derived on your device, non-extractable and memory-only | Zero-access encryption of stored history |
| Sync across devices | Yes — including offline-queued chats on reconnect | Yes — synced encrypted history |
| Model choice | On-device models + 16+ providers via BYOK | Proton's served models only |
| Trust pedigree | Independent product built in public; honest limits published (default chats stored server-side; free shared mode transits the server) | A decade of audited privacy credentials, Swiss jurisdiction, institutional reputation |
Landscape checked Nov 2026. Every checkmark is a shipped, verifiable behavior — not a roadmap item.
Where Proton Lumo wins
- Institutional trust: audits, Swiss legal protection and a ten-year track record you can point a compliance team at
- Polish and support of a mature privacy company behind it
- A name enterprises already recognize
The verdict
Lumo is the strongest brand in encrypted AI — and it still needs the internet, an account, and Proton's servers seeing your prompt in cleartext to answer it. ShadowTalk covers the intersection Lumo can't reach: on-device inference that never touches a network, offline chat that queues and syncs, and encryption you hold the keys to. If institutional pedigree is your top requirement, Lumo is a fine choice; if 'nothing sees my prompt' is the requirement, that's the on-device tier.
One honest asymmetry to weigh: Lumo's zero-access storage is its default; ShadowTalk's end-to-end encryption is opt-in Private Mode, and we document exactly what the defaults do instead. ShadowTalk is the first AI chat in a browser that works offline and syncs when you're back — encrypted AI that also survives the tunnel.
Frequently asked questions
Keep reading
Free to use — no account, no card.
Works offline. Syncs when you're back. Your keys, your models, your chats.
Try encrypted + offline AI — free